Proposal 3:

Restoring Roe With All Eyes on Michigan

A coalition and vendor team crafted a cohesive message, compelling creative, and ultimately won a tough campaign to protect choice for millions.

Challenge

Help persuade and turnout voters to vote “Yes” on 3 and protect choice in Michigan.

Solution

Produce effective creative, test all creative rigorously, and run strategic advertising to help persuade voters, turn out voters, and win.

A Complicated Landscape and Reproductive Health Care At Stake

In 2022, Michigan was one of six states with an abortion amendment on the ballot, the only one of those deemed a battleground state, and the first “Yes” ballot initiative campaign regarding abortion rights in decades. The stakes were extremely high, with real-world consequences for Michiganders and for the nation. It was critical to persuade and drive voters to the polls in support of Proposal 3 to restore the rights citizens had under Roe vs. Wade. All eyes were on Michigan.

Our goal was to reach voters who had a demonstrated belief that Roe should stand, but needed to be persuaded that passing Proposal 3 was the best way to maintain the status quo in Michigan, and that there were serious consequences if it failed. This audience skewed moderate – many of these voters may not have personally supported abortion, but agreed that it is health care and should be available without government intervention.

With just 12 weeks between launch and Election Day, we knew our messaging needed to be airtight. It was informed by polling, confirmed by creative testing, and then echoed across all mediums. While the style and messengers changed, there was a high level of message discipline across the team.

TIMELINE

Phases of the campaign

PHASE 1.

defining proposal 3

PHASE 2.

validation from doctors

PHASE 3.

abortion stories and consequences

PHASE 4.

closing arguments and refuting misinformation

From August to November 2022, we ran numerous randomized controlled trials (sometimes called creative tests) that included over fifty videos and two dozen assets specifically produced for digital advertising. Videos tested ranged in effectiveness from 0.3% to 8.6% lift! This allowed us to run only the most effective ads.

Because we were continuously putting our ads into testing, we were able to nimbly swap out creative and ensure that our campaigns were using the most persuasive and effective messaging throughout. This meant that voters were consistently seeing new creative–allowing our heavy-saturation campaign to break through a noisy election ad environment.

We believe that using the highest testing ads over the lowest testing resulted in hundreds of thousands of minds changed.

Our digital and streaming TV ads strategy was multi-faceted, including:
Overall, the digital effort delivered over 300 million impressions to just over 4 million voters, including ads in English, Spanish, and Arabic. This effort along with the TV, field, mail, and grassroots efforts of those involved in the campaign, led to a historic win in red and blue counties alike.

Winning Across the State

Because of our surround sound approach and our efforts to talk to voters wherever they were, Proposal 3 performed strongly all across the state. From rural, conservative areas in the Upper Peninsula to densely liberal Washtenaw county. Our message resonated with voters of all backgrounds and political persuasions.

This win was even more impressive when considering it was the first “YES” campaign in decades and the only 2022 “YES” choice measure in purple or swing state.

Additionally, it helped drive pro-choice turnout making Michigan one of only 8 states with increased turnout over 2018.

Winning Results

Just a week before the election, a tracking poll from Cygnal had support for Prop 3 up 10%. The final results out preformed both public polls like this one and internal support tracking.

YES
52%
NO
43%
On Election Day, Michigan voters resoundingly approved Proposal 3.
YES
56.7% VOTES: 2,482,382
NO
43.3% VOTES: 1,898,906

Not only did Proposal 3 win, but it outperformed both internal and public polls, winning by an overwhelming 13 points

Awards Won

8 Pollies

Gold

Digital – Ballot Initiative Division – Website
Reproductive Freedom for All
A Website to Protect Reproductive Freedom, Fight Misinformation, and Persuade Michiganders to Vote YES on 3!

 

Silver

Overall – Ballot Initiative Division – Best Digital Campaign
Reproductive Freedom for All
Impactful Creative & Airtight Messaging: Passing Proposal 3 in Michigan through Digital Persuasion

 

Overall – Ballot Initiative Division – Best In Show
Reproductive Freedom for All
Reprodutive Freedom For All

 

Digital – Ballot Initiative Division – Digital Creative – Stand Alone
Reproductive Freedom for All
Dr. Basha’s Story

 

Bronze

Overall – Miscellaneous Division – Best New and Unusual Tactic
Reproductive Freedom for All
Dr. Basha’s Story

 

Overall – Miscellaneous Division – Best Data Analytics Solution
Reproductive Freedom for All
Abortion Stories & Prop 3 in Michigan: Using
Creative Testing to Craft Winning Messages

 

Digital – Ballot Initiative Division – Best Use of Social Media
Reproductive Freedom for All
Meeting People Where They Are: Prop 3 on Social Media in Michigan

 

Digital – Ballot Initiative Division – Digital Creative – Stand Alone
Reproductive Freedom for All
“Imagine This” – Telling the Story of a Future without Prop 3

 

1 Addy

Silver

Public Service Online Film, Video & Sound
Reproductive Freedom for All
Dr. Basha’s Story

Since CMG started in 2012, we’ve helped more than 400 clients make a difference with award winning projects. Check out the comprehensive list!

Stay updated

Don’t worry—we promise it’s the good stuff, only the occasional email!

Let’s work together